14 Best Bike Saddle After Prostate Surgery (2022 Updated)

Several years ago I bought a white Selle Pro for my TREK Madone. While it took me a few rides to get used to, I came to love it. I recently bought a black/gray Cannondale Synapse. It had an attractive looking saddle that matched the bike that was a smooth padded (slippery) plastic.

Although it looked nice, after a few rides I felt strongly that I wanted a Selle Pro saddle for this bike as well, as I wanted the same support and comfort (which means you forget that there is a saddle under you, as I do long rides regularly).

The Selle Pro is not cheap but I thought it was worth it so I ordered a black saddle for my new bike. The first thing you notice when you open the box is the smell, just like a fine Italian leather boot, as well as the quality of the leather on the saddle.

This is the real deal of materials and craftsmanship! Right away I thought: this was the right decision, a quality bike should have a quality saddle given the number of hours/miles of use. Having the benefit of how/where to position it from my TREK, I installed it on the Synapse and off I went.

A happy camper! For me, the Pro provides comfort, avoids a number of butt related issues I had with other saddles, and confirms that craftsmanship, quality and natural materials still counts for something, albeit ata price.

The Pro is an example of getting what you pay for. Glad I bought a second. I deserve it, as do you.

Had two of these saddles over the last 10 yrs after wasting hundreds on poor fits. I’m 177cm tall, weigh 90kgs, have medium width pelvis and ride approximately 250k a week. Ideal pressure point relief , great ventilation and beautifully crafted.

Expensive but worth every cent.

This saddle was highly recommended by an avid road rider, and I thought I had finally found a saddle perfect for a gravel bike that’s used for a 50k return commute 3x week that would work with or without cycling shorts (assuming a small height adjustment depending on attire).

Proper measured sit bone width. This seat was truly torture. It may work for you. Ended up with a narrower (technically 2mm too narrow) seat that was intended for my husband, also a Selle Italia, but it also was torturous in different ways (another review for another day).

He preferred this saddle by a long shot. So it may work for you. Two stars for quality, but subjective comfort definitely one star.

I bought two of these a year ago for road riding and they have been the most comfortable saddles I have used for long rides and minimizing pressure points/discomfort. I realize this is going to be specific to each individuals anthropometry (pelvic shape/size/muscularity).

Definitely not the lightest version of this saddle, as been noted by the titanium vs magnesium description issues, however magnesium is the less dense metal, so should be lighter than a titanium version of the same saddle.

The strength to weight ratio of the metals is roughly the same, which would make titanium rails stronger and more durable than this magnesium version for those using it off road or if you are a heavier individual concerned about structural integrity of the saddle.

Nice looking saddle, sleek lines, Sella Italia quality and construction. Firm padding, adequate give but not a cushy surface. Comfortable for road riding the tops and drops, doesnt let me ride on the aero bars for extended periods (could tilt down more but then one would slide forward when in an upright riding position).

So I dont recommend for tri or TT. Also ride Sella Italia SLR Kit Carbonio, which is comparable in feel and comfort. Also have tried Specialized Romin & Fizik Arione which for me are both less comfortable.

This is an excellent saddle. I have tried all major brands and find this is to the best yet. Firm but well padded. Deep and wide cutout works perfectly for me. I’ve had a chance to ride it a few times now working my way up to 2 hours continuous riding and and found no numbness or discomfort whatsoever.

I am confident that it will be perfect for longer rides of 100 km or more as well. All this at a very competitive price. Solid 5 stars for comfort, product quality and value.

The Ergon SR Pro is, without question, the best and most comfortable saddle I have ever owned. and I go through racing saddles like other people go through socks, trying to find the perfect blend of comfort and performance.

It literally feels like there is almost nothing between my legs. Although firm, the OrthoCell inserts in the sit bone area work like magic. I mounted it on my trainer and couldn’t believe how good it felt, then switched to a couple of my other favourite saddles and they felt like crap in comparison.

I’ve already ordered another one (for my wife) and will be ordering SR Pros for my other bikes, too.

I have burned through multiple saddles the last several months trying to find one that doesn’t produce numbness and pressure points. In this saddle, I have finally found the one. I have taken it for several multiple hour rides on my road and gravel bike as well as several hours in the trainer, and it is the best saddle I have found so far.

I will be ordering at least one more. My search is over.

I used this one my Canyon Neuron which came with a pretty generic seat. It was very difficult to ride the bike for prolonged periods. Comparing to this one is day and night. Much more comfortable, and I can even ride the bike without the bicycle pants that has extra protection!The foam inside is not that thick but does a great job to keep you butt comfortable without adding extra weight to the bicycle.

It’s actually lighter than my original seat. A++.

As a male I consider the gap in the centre of the extremely important. It allows comfortable seating without the uncomfortable chafing. The memory foam means the foam in the seat springs back and gives good cushioning.

I now can do longer rides without feeling uncomfortable and sore.

Really small and pretty uncomfortable. I’m 187m and about 87kg, I don’t recommend for bumpy roads or long rides. Thanks.

I originally looked at ISM ADAMO as a product which stands behind its high price. Upon first looks, it is an impressive saddle. However, when turning it over, there are obvious signs of cheap craftsmanship and finish.

Staples, uneven sewing, leftover material, and made in China. Not the quality I’d expect from a company like ISM. In summary: It may be a comfortable seat, but you can also buy saddles with similar comfort, at a fraction of the price of an ISM, and they look better too.

Would I buy another? Certainly not worth the money. No thanks.

I was using a standard tri saddle for a few years but often struggled with numbness in the family geneology department. I took my TT bike to three different fitting experts. They were not wrong, just not completely right either.

After buying this saddle I had some getting used to but its absolutely wonderful as it opened my hips and I can really turn and burn comfortably. I reccomend locking your arms in the aero position and arching your back as your cradle yourself in the saddle and you will just fly.

Great Job ISM!.

After approximately 1000 miles in the last 4-5 weeks, including a 210 mile and 156 mile ride, this saddle is proving to be the best and most comfortable of the 5 or 6 others I’ve tried over the last 3-5 years, including a Brooks B17, Specialized Power, Fizik Arione, Ergon, and others.

It may not work for your anatomy and bib short combination, but it appears to be just what mine needed. Good luck!.

I’ve been riding bikes for 50 years and tried almost every saddle under the sun. This one is the most comfortable one I have ever ridden. A tad on the heavy side if you are a weight weenie and a tad on the expensive side as well.

But for comfort it cannot be beat and as much time as I spend on my bikes the expense is well worth it. I had to spend some time to get it set up just right but once I hit the sweet spot was simply astounded how good it felt.

I did a 25 mile nonstop ride the other day with zero saddle discomfort.

As expected. A little hard bur good for longer rides. I use this saddle in combo with a spring seat post on a e-bike.

This seat is quite comfy! I like the cutout in the center to allow maximum blood flow.

read reviews so purchased one to try spent a bit of time setting it up and it works well. purchased two more for my other bikes. great for long rides takes all the weight in the right place on your bottom.

I bought this saddle to help my husband with a prostate problem. He finds it beneficial as it relieves the pressure on a sensitive area. This is his second, and no doubt he will go on to have one for each of his bikes.

As any other SMP, this is a great seat. Given that this is their entry level seat, some details are overlooked (like sharp lower edges of the molding up front that can become a problem for heavier riders, but not necessarily.

Still I would have expected them to smooth those out. Otherwise, this is a great seat that completely transforms the on-bike experience. Interestingly enough, both my brother (200+ lbs) and my GF (105 lbs) use this seat model and love it.

Finally found a seat that fits me. With 13. 5cm sit bones, I’ve tried many saddles, and all felt too small. This one is just right, and the gel adds to the comfort. It’s not too hard or too soft, offering the right balance for 3-4 hour trail rides.

Takes a few rides to break it in.

I. was. not. happy. with. this saddle. it. was. far. to. wide and. to. heavy. it. did. look comfortable. but. not. suiterble for. my. GT. . mountain. bike so. I. had. to. return. it. for a. . refund.

This saddle is comfortable but I’m not sure how long it will last. The saddle that came with my Tern bike seems more substantial but not as soft as the Selle Royal. I hope to be proved wrong regarding durability – time will tell.

One thing I’ve noticed is that the saddles on new bikes are always butt kickers! I just bought my third WTB Speed Progel (one each for my XC, enduro and hardtail). They are the perfect balance of cushion and weight.

Yes, I sacrifice some extra poundage for the comfort, but honestly soft and comfy cheeks improve my speed far more than saving a few ounces. Besides that, I’m not at risk at winning any races any way.

I easily ride 3-4 hours and instead of bruises I come home with smiles! Next to a good dropper post, this is the most essential upgrade for any MTB!.

I got this to replace the Bontrager saddle on my Trek Remedy that is mostly used for XC and trail. I had previous experience with WTB saddles and their medium width generally fit me well, so no big surprises here.

In general, it’s comfy with a bit of a drop in the nose to keep things out of the way. Reasonable but not excessive padding. I’ve used this with both padded and unpadded shorts and it works fine with both.

Not the lightest saddle around but the reality of my situation is that I can always lose an ounce or too off my body, so that’s not my prime concern in most equipment (there are lighter versions of the same design for more $$$ if you care).

As with any saddle, the major issue is fit. WTB are somewhat notorious as either “they fit you or they don’t. ” My experience is that they fit me well and I won’t hesitate to buy another. PROS: Durable, Easy To Install, Attractive Design.