Social Moms

Best Pacifier For Breastfed Baby Who Won’T Take One (2023 Update)

When you shop through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. This educational content is not intended to be a substitute for professional advice.

If you’re looking for the best pacifier for your breastfed baby who won’t take one, you may be wondering where to start. There are seemingly endless options on the market, and not all pacifiers are created equal. Before making a purchase, there are several important factors to consider.

First, you’ll want to think about the shape and size of the pacifier. Babies who are breastfed may prefer pacifiers that are shaped more like a nipple, so look for options that mimic this shape. Next, consider the material of the pacifier. Many parents prefer silicone pacifiers as they are easy to clean and won’t retain odors like rubber pacifiers can.

Lastly, you may want to consider special features such as a built-in nightlight or the ability to play soothing sounds. While these may not be necessary, they can be helpful in calming a fussy baby.

Are you struggling to find a pacifier that your breastfed baby will take? Have you tried multiple options with no luck? Or are you a new parent unsure of where to start? This article will guide you through the factors to consider when choosing the best pacifier for your little one. Keep reading to discover the pacifier that will provide comfort to both you and your baby.

10 Best Pacifier For Breastfed Baby Who Won'T Take One

# Product Image Product Name Product Notes Check Price
1

The product is ideal for promoting healthy dental development in babies over 9 months old, with a pack of three BPA-free silicone pacifiers.

2

This product is ideal for soothing newborn babies with a BPA-free, glow-in-the-dark pacifier.

3

The product is ideal for soothing infants and providing a secure attachment with a pacifier clip.

4

The product is ideal for keeping a pacifier secure and within reach for a newborn baby.

5

The product is ideal for soothing breastfed babies, helping them find their pacifier in the dark.

6

The product is ideal for soothing newborns and young infants with its silicone pacifiers featuring collapsible handles and two air holes.

7

This product is ideal for breastfed babies with sensitive skin aged 6 months or older, and comes with a sterilizing case.

8

This product is ideal for soothing babies between the ages of 6-18 months with symmetrical and safe pacifiers.

9

This product is ideal for babies between the ages of 18-36 months who use pacifiers made with BPA-free silicone material.

10

The product is ideal for soothing and pacifying breastfeeding babies and is a perfect baby registry gift.

The product is ideal for promoting healthy dental development in babies over 9 months old, with a pack of three BPA-free silicone pacifiers.

This product is ideal for soothing newborn babies with a BPA-free, glow-in-the-dark pacifier.

The product is ideal for soothing infants and providing a secure attachment with a pacifier clip.

The product is ideal for keeping a pacifier secure and within reach for a newborn baby.

The product is ideal for soothing breastfed babies, helping them find their pacifier in the dark.

The product is ideal for soothing newborns and young infants with its silicone pacifiers featuring collapsible handles and two air holes.

This product is ideal for breastfed babies with sensitive skin aged 6 months or older, and comes with a sterilizing case.

This product is ideal for soothing babies between the ages of 6-18 months with symmetrical and safe pacifiers.

This product is ideal for babies between the ages of 18-36 months who use pacifiers made with BPA-free silicone material.

The product is ideal for soothing and pacifying breastfeeding babies and is a perfect baby registry gift.

1. Healthy Smiles Pacifier Trio – Aqua Blue

Smilo Pacifiers are the perfect solution for parents looking for high-quality, comfortable, and safe pacifiers for their babies. The pacifiers are designed with the help of a leading Pediatric Dentist, ensuring that they are not only soothing but also promote healthy dental development and prevent crossbiting.

The unique Orthodontic Design of the nipple expands during soothing, which helps to encourage healthy dental development. This design is patented and has been developed with the utmost care to ensure that it meets all the necessary standards.

The Comfortable Shape of the pacifier is another feature that makes it stand out. The shield is curved to provide enough space for easy breathing, while two openings allow air to flow through the shield to prevent moisture build-up and protect your baby's sensitive skin. This ensures that your little one can breathe comfortably while using the pacifier.

Smilo Pacifiers are made from Medical Grade Material, which is 100% silicone and BPA-free. The pacifiers are assembled in the US, ensuring that they meet all the necessary safety standards. They are also dishwasher safe, making them easy to clean and maintain.

The pacifiers are available in four stages, ranging from 0-9+ months, ensuring that you can find the right size and fit for your baby. This size system makes it easy for parents to choose the right pacifier for their little one.

The Smilo Pacifiers come in a pack of three, with bold colors and unique designs that are perfect for both boys and girls. They make an ideal gift for baby showers, ensuring that parents have a high-quality and safe pacifier for their little one.

2. Glow-In-The-Dark Pacifiers For Babies

Introducing the Stage 1 Glow-in-the-Dark Pacifiers from Mama Bear – a set of four pacifiers in assorted colors that is perfect for newborns and infants up to six months old. However, every baby is unique, so it’s important to keep in mind that while the Stage 1 nipple size is recommended for this age range, your baby may prefer a different size regardless of their age. If your little one needs a bigger nipple size, you can try Mama Bear Stage 2 (6-12M) Pacifiers.

These pacifiers come with soft glow-in-the-dark illuminations that make it easy to find them at night. Simply expose them to light to charge them up. The glow is soft and gentle, so it won’t disturb your baby’s sleep.

The nipple is made of 100% silicone and is BPA-free, making it safe for your baby to use. The butterfly-shaped shield is designed to provide a comfortable fit around your baby’s nose and cheeks, ensuring that they can use the pacifier without any discomfort.

Cleaning these pacifiers is a breeze – they are dishwasher safe in the top rack. However, it’s important to note that you should never tie the pacifier around your child’s neck as it poses a strangulation danger.

Mama Bear is proud of its products, and they offer a satisfaction guarantee. If you’re not completely satisfied with your purchase, you can get a full refund within a year of purchase.

3. Dr. Brown's Advantage Symmetrical Pacifier With Air Flow & Pacifier Clip, Pink, 2-Pack, 0-6m

Introducing the fully symmetrical soother for reversible positioning, the perfect solution for your little one's needs. Made from 100% silicone, the bulb boasts a rounded shape that satisfies suckling reflexes, providing ultimate comfort for your baby. The unique shield design of this soother reduces irritation by allowing your baby's skin to breathe, keeping them happy and content.

This soother comes in two stages to ensure it grows with your baby, providing long-lasting use. The pacifier clip features a closed-loop design and strong metal clasp that safely secures to your baby's pacifier, reducing the likelihood of it being lost or dropped.

The soother is taste-free, odor-free, and BPA-free, ensuring your baby's safety and comfort at all times. For your convenience, it is both dishwasher (top rack) and sterilizer safe, making cleaning a breeze.

Invest in the fully symmetrical soother for reversible positioning today and ensure your baby's comfort and safety.

4. Philips Avent Soothie Snuggle Pacifier Holder With Detachable Pacifier, 0m+, Giraffe, Scf347/01

Introducing the perfect solution for parents looking to soothe their newborns! This pacifier and stuffed animal set is designed with both babies and parents in mind. The set includes the popular 0-3 month Soothie pacifier, which is trusted and used by doctors and nurses to calm newborns.

The pacifier and stuffed animal are easy to clean, as they detach from each other seamlessly. This makes it easy for parents to keep the pacifier and stuffed animal hygienic and safe for their little ones.

The stuffed animal is not only adorable, but also serves a practical purpose. It helps parents and babies locate the pacifier easily when needed. Additionally, the stuffed animal keeps the pacifier close to the baby, ensuring that it does not get lost or misplaced.

For even more convenience, the stuffed animal has a second attachment point for pacifiers with ring handles. This feature ensures that the set is versatile and can be used with a variety of pacifiers.

5. Mam Night Pacifiers 0-6 Months, Best For Breastfed Babies, Glow In The Dark, Baby Boy, 2 Count

Introducing the MAM Night Pacifiers, a set of two pacifiers that are designed to provide comfort and convenience to both babies and parents. These pacifiers are a great addition to your baby's bedtime routine as they glow in the dark, making them easy to locate quickly at night without any stumbling and searching. This feature ensures that your baby can sleep better, allowing you to enjoy a peaceful night's rest as well.

The pacifiers have a symmetrical design that is both fun and functional. The curved shield with wide openings is always right-side up, preventing skin irritation with maximum airflow. This design ensures that your baby's delicate skin is protected and that they can breathe comfortably as they sleep.

The MAM Night Pacifiers are made from BPA-free silicone and have the signature MAM design. The silky SkinSoft material and symmetrical shape make them ideal for jaw and teeth development. These pacifiers are suitable for both baby boys and girls and are designed for babies aged 0-6 months.

One of the standout features of the MAM Night Pacifiers is the self-sterilizing case. This case allows you to sterilize the pacifiers in just three minutes by adding water and popping them into the microwave. This feature is incredibly convenient, making it easy to keep your baby's pacifiers clean and hygienic at all times. The case can also be used to store the pacifiers at home or during travel, protecting them from dirt and dust.

6. Sweetie Soother Pacifiers – Dark Gray & Yellow

Introducing the newborn pacifier 2-pack, the perfect solution to soothe your little one. The set includes two pacifiers made of 100% food grade silicone, ensuring that your baby stays safe and comfortable while using them. Each pacifier features two large vent holes for easy breathability, making it easier for your little one to use.

The coordinating set includes two pacifiers in dark gray and yellow, both of which feature a braided design detail on the collapsible handle. This design makes it easier for parents to coordinate with their baby's outfits, making the pacifiers not only practical but stylish as well.

The pacifiers have been safety tested to meet ASTM safety standards, ensuring that they are secure for your baby to use. The pacifiers feature a single-part design and a collapsible handle, reducing the risk of choking and adding extra safety.

The pacifiers feature a proven nipple shape that is soft and durable, making them the perfect choice for newborns and up. They can even be used when your baby's teeth are coming in, ensuring that they provide comfort for a long time.

7. Mam's Top Picks For Your Baby's Pacifier Needs

The MAM Breastfeed Pacifier is a must-have for parents with babies who have sensitive skin. The pacifier features large air holes that provide ample breathing room for your little one, while allowing you to steal a quick peek at their adorable smile.

What's more, this pacifier glows in the dark, making it easy to locate during nighttime feedings without any fumbling or searching. This feature can help your baby sleep better by minimizing disruptions to their sleep schedule.

The pacifier boasts a BPA-free silicone nipple that is designed with the signature MAM silky SkinSoft material and a symmetrical shape. This shape is ideal for the development of your baby's jaw and teeth. The silicone nipple is also available in a variety of fun designs for both boys and girls.

As a bonus, the pacifier comes with a self-sterilizing case. Simply add water and pop it into the microwave for three minutes to sterilize the pacifier. The case is perfect for storing the pacifiers at home or on-the-go, protecting them from dirt and germs.

MAM's silicone pacifiers are of the highest quality, approved by 94% of babies*. They are 100% BPA and BPS-free, meeting or exceeding US safety standards. The pacifiers are extremely durable while still being soft and flexible for your baby's comfort.

8. Tommee Tippee Fun Style Pacifiers, Symmetrical Design, Bpa-Free Silicone Binkies, 6-18m, 4-Count

The Tommee Tippee Fun Style pacifier is an excellent choice for parents who want to provide their little ones with a comfortable and safe pacifier. Its symmetrical design ensures that the pacifier will always be placed correctly in the baby's mouth, thanks to its silicone nipple that has no 'wrong' side up. This feature guarantees that the baby will use the pacifier without any discomfort.

The pacifier is made of 100% medical-grade, BPA-free silicone, which is soft, flexible, and extremely durable. It won't absorb stains and odors and is easy to clean. It has been tested and accepted by 97.5% of babies, making it a reliable and trustworthy option for parents.

The curved shield of the pacifier provides a comfortable fit between the baby's nose and chin, preventing any discomfort or irritation. Moreover, the pacifier's large holes allow extra air flow and prevent moisture build-up, ensuring the baby's skin stays dry and healthy.

Loved by moms and babies, the Fun Style pacifiers are highly recommended. 99% of moms who have used them reported that they would recommend them to other parents. The pacifiers are perfect for settling babies and keeping them calm and happy.

The Fun Style pacifiers come in bright and playful designs with fun characters suitable for use anytime, anywhere. They are perfect for parents who want to add a touch of fun and personality to their baby's accessories.

9. Silicone Symmetrical Pacifiers For Day And Night

The Tommee Tippee pacifiers are designed with a symmetrical silicone nipple, ensuring that there is no wrong side up, and it will always be placed correctly in the baby's mouth. These pacifiers have an acceptance rate of 97.5% among babies, thanks to the 100% medical-grade, BPA-free silicone baglet. This baglet is soft, flexible, and highly durable, ensuring that it won't absorb stains and odors.

These pacifiers are kind on the baby's skin, thanks to the curved shield that ensures a comfortable fit between the baby's nose and chin. The large holes on the shield allow extra air flow and prevent moisture build-up, which helps to prevent skin irritation.

Recommended by moms and loved by babies, these binkies help to settle the baby, with 99% of moms reporting that they would recommend our pacifiers to others. The package includes two Every Day pacifiers with modern but understated designs suitable for everyday use and one Night Time pacifier featuring a glow-in-the-dark handle.

10. Nanobebe Ortho Pacifiers: Breastfeeding-Friendly 2pk

Introducing the Flexy Pacifier – a pacifier designed to provide the most comfortable fit for your little one. Made with 100% silicone, this pacifier has a soft and ergonomic design that curves comfortably around your baby's face, nose, and chin while staying perfectly in place.

The seamless, one-piece silicone design of the Flexy Pacifier is recommended by pediatricians and adheres to the American Academy of Pediatrics guidelines for safe pacifiers. It is also BPA and Phthalate-free, ensuring that your baby is safe from harmful chemicals.

This award-winning pacifier is highly recommended for breastfed babies as its ultra-soft silicone feels like skin and eliminates nipple confusion, making it easier to calm and soothe your little one. Newborns will love it from the very first moment.

Cleaning the Flexy Pacifier is a breeze thanks to its one-piece construction. It is sterilizer and dishwasher safe, making it easy to maintain its cleanliness and hygiene.

Excitingly, the Flexy Pacifier now has a new Stage 2 Flexy Active Pacifier variation. This new pacifier features open side vents that provide additional airflow and an ultra-lightweight construction that is perfect for infants on the move – from crawling to walking and more.

Best Pacifier For Breastfed Baby Who Won'T Take One FAQs

Are there any natural or homemade remedies that can help soothe a breastfed baby who won't take a pacifier?

Yes, there are some natural or homemade remedies that can help soothe a breastfed baby who won't take a pacifier. Here are some suggestions:

1. Skin-to-skin contact: Place the baby on your bare chest and let them feel your warmth, heartbeat, and smell. This can have a calming effect on many babies.

2. Swaddling: Wrap the baby snugly in a blanket, which can mimic the feeling of being in the womb and provide a sense of security.

3. Rocking or bouncing: Gently rock or bounce the baby in your arms or in a baby swing or rocker.

4. White noise: Play calming sounds, such as white noise or nature sounds, to help soothe the baby.

5. Breastfeeding: If the baby is hungry, offer the breast for comfort and nourishment.

6. Chamomile tea: Brew some chamomile tea and let it cool down. Give a small amount to the baby to help calm them down.

It's important to keep in mind that every baby is different, so what works for one may not work for another. It's also important to consult with a healthcare provider before trying any new remedies.

Can using a pacifier interfere with breastfeeding or cause nipple confusion in breastfed babies?

Using a pacifier can sometimes interfere with breastfeeding or cause nipple confusion in breastfed babies. However, it largely depends on how and when the pacifier is used. If the baby is latching and feeding well, introducing a pacifier after breastfeeding is established (usually around 3-4 weeks) should not cause any problems. But, if a pacifier is introduced too early or used excessively, it can interfere with the baby's ability to latch and breastfeed effectively. This is because pacifiers require a different sucking technique than breastfeeding, and using a pacifier too frequently can lead to nipple confusion or a preference for the pacifier over the breast. Therefore, it's important to use a pacifier in moderation and to wait until breastfeeding is well established before introducing one. It's always a good idea to consult with a lactation consultant or your healthcare provider if you have any concerns or questions regarding pacifier use and breastfeeding.

How do you choose the right type of pacifier for a breastfed baby who won't take one?

Choosing the right type of pacifier for a breastfed baby who won't take one can be a challenging task. However, there are a few things that you can keep in mind while selecting a pacifier. Firstly, opt for a pacifier that is specifically designed for breastfed babies. Look for pacifiers that mimic the shape of a nipple, as they are more likely to be accepted by your baby. Secondly, choose a pacifier that is made of safe and non-toxic materials. Avoid pacifiers with strong odors or flavors, as they may put your baby off. Thirdly, consider the size and shape of the pacifier. Make sure that the pacifier is the right size for your baby's mouth and that it feels comfortable. Lastly, try different pacifiers until you find one that your baby likes. Remember that it may take a few attempts before your baby accepts a pacifier, so be patient and persistent. If your baby still refuses to take a pacifier, you may want to seek advice from a lactation consultant or your pediatrician.

How do you introduce a pacifier to a breastfed baby who has never used one before?

Introducing a pacifier to a breastfed baby who has never used one before can be a tricky task. Here are some tips to introduce a pacifier to your breastfed baby:

1. Wait until breastfeeding is fully established: It's best to wait until your baby is at least 4-6 weeks old and breastfeeding is well established before introducing a pacifier.

2. Choose the right time: Choose a time when your baby is calm and relaxed, and not too hungry or too full.

3. Choose the right pacifier: Choose a pacifier that is designed specifically for breastfed babies, with a nipple that is shaped like a breast.

4. Offer the pacifier gently: Offer the pacifier gently by stroking your baby's lips with the pacifier.

5. Don't force it: If your baby doesn't want the pacifier, don't force it. Try again later.

6. Limit pacifier use: Limit pacifier use to sleep time or times when your baby needs soothing.

Remember, introducing a pacifier to a breastfed baby is a personal decision. Some babies may not need a pacifier at all, while others may take to it easily. Always consult with your pediatrician if you have any concerns.

Is it ever necessary to use a pacifier for a breastfed baby who won't take one, or are there other alternatives to consider?

It is not always necessary to use a pacifier for a breastfed baby who won't take one. Breastfed babies may not always take to pacifiers because they have different suckling patterns than bottle-fed babies. However, there are other alternatives to consider such as offering a clean finger to suck on or using a teething toy that is safe for babies to chew on. It is important to note that pacifiers should never be forced on a baby, as it may interfere with breastfeeding and cause nipple confusion. Additionally, if a baby is not interested in using a pacifier, it is perfectly fine to not use one at all. The American Academy of Pediatrics recommends waiting until breastfeeding is well-established before introducing a pacifier, around 3-4 weeks of age, and to limit pacifier use once breastfeeding is established. Ultimately, it is up to the parents to decide what works best for their baby and family.

What are some tips for getting a breastfed baby who won't take a pacifier to use one?

Introducing a pacifier to a breastfed baby can be a challenging task as they are used to the natural sucking motion of breastfeeding. However, here are some tips to encourage your baby to use a pacifier:

1. Try different types of pacifiers: Some babies are picky and prefer specific shapes or materials, so try different types until you find one your baby likes.

2. Offer the pacifier at the right time: Wait until your baby is calm and relaxed, and try offering the pacifier during a feeding or when they're falling asleep.

3. Use breast milk or formula: Put some breast milk or formula on the pacifier to make it more familiar and pleasant for your baby.

4. Be patient: It may take some time for your baby to get used to the pacifier, so be patient and keep trying.

5. Don't force it: If your baby still refuses the pacifier, don't force them to use it. Some babies simply don't like pacifiers, and that's okay.

Remember, not all babies will take a pacifier, and that's okay. If your baby doesn't like pacifiers, you can try other soothing techniques such as swaddling or rocking.

What are the most recommended brands of pacifiers for breastfed babies who won't take one?

When it comes to pacifiers for breastfed babies who won't take one, there are a few recommended brands that have proven to be successful for many parents. One of the most popular brands is the Philips Avent Soothie Pacifier, which is designed to mimic the shape and feel of a breast nipple. Another brand that is highly recommended is the Mam Pacifier, which features a unique nipple design that helps to promote healthy oral development and reduce the risk of dental issues. The NUK Orthodontic Pacifier is also a great option, as it is designed to promote proper jaw and teeth alignment. Lastly, the Chicco NaturalFit Pacifier is another favorite among parents, as it is made with soft, flexible silicone and has a unique nipple shape that is similar to a breast. Ultimately, it may take some trial and error to find the right pacifier for your breastfed baby, but these brands are a good place to start.

What are the potential benefits of using a pacifier for breastfed babies who won't take one?

Using a pacifier for breastfed babies who won't take one can have potential benefits. Here are some of them:

1. Soothing Effect: Pacifiers can provide a calming effect for babies, which can help them to fall asleep more easily and stay asleep longer. This can be particularly helpful for parents who are struggling with sleep deprivation.

2. Reduced Risk of SIDS: Studies have shown that the use of pacifiers during sleep can reduce the risk of Sudden Infant Death Syndrome (SIDS) by up to 50%.

3. Reduced Risk of Ear Infections: The act of sucking on a pacifier can help to equalize the pressure in a baby's ears, which can reduce the risk of ear infections.

4. Improved Sucking Technique: Some breastfed babies may have difficulty latching on properly, and using a pacifier can help them to develop a better sucking technique, which can ultimately improve their ability to breastfeed.

It's important to note, however, that the American Academy of Pediatrics recommends waiting to introduce a pacifier until breastfeeding is well established (usually around 3-4 weeks) to avoid nipple confusion. It's also important to choose a pacifier that is the right size and shape for your baby and to always supervise your baby while they are using it.

What features should you look for in a pacifier that might entice a breastfed baby to use it?

If you are a breastfeeding mother and want to introduce a pacifier to your baby, there are a few features that you should look for in a pacifier that might entice your baby to use it. Firstly, the pacifier should be made up of soft and flexible material that is similar to the texture of a mother's nipple. This will enable the baby to feel more comfortable while using the pacifier. Secondly, the shape of the pacifier should mimic the shape of a mother's nipple. This will help the baby to suck and latch onto the pacifier more easily. Thirdly, the pacifier should have a slow flow rate of milk that simulates the flow of breast milk. This will help the baby to feel more comfortable while using the pacifier. Lastly, the pacifier should be easy to clean and sterilize to ensure the baby's safety and hygiene. By considering these features, you can select a pacifier that is more likely to be accepted by your breastfed baby.

What makes a pacifier suitable for breastfed babies who refuse one?

Breastfed babies who refuse pacifiers can be challenging for parents, but there are a few features that make pacifiers more suitable for them. Firstly, the pacifier should mimic the shape of the mother's nipple to make the baby more likely to accept it. A pacifier with a round or flat nipple may not feel like the breast and be rejected by the baby. Secondly, the pacifier should be made of soft, flexible, and safe materials that are similar to the breast. Silicone or latex pacifiers are good options. Thirdly, the pacifier should have a small and lightweight shield that doesn't interfere with the baby's latch or cause discomfort. Lastly, the pacifier should be easy to clean and sterilize to maintain proper hygiene. Parents can try different pacifiers until they find one that their baby accepts, and they should always supervise their baby when using a pacifier to prevent any choking hazards.

Sharing is caring!

Similar Posts