20 Best Cat Treats For Picky Cats (2022 Updated)

The new indoor treats are not hairball treats like the previous bag. The previous bag contains Petroleum which is needed for safe hairball removal (Vet is family, verified). This explains why the package does not list hairball control like the previous.

Though you claim the beet pulp and cellulose are the hairball treatments, they are no way comparable to the previous main ingredient of petroleum. Cats need this or glycerin for safe removal. Please update this and let customers know as this can be life or death for pets and their owners trying to control their hairball issue.

Why, did remyou ove this ingredient anyway?.

In no way, shape, or form are these Indoor Care Treats a substitute of any kind much less identical to the hairball formula. One worked wonderfully for my long-haired Persian especially but my other as well and this Indoor Care does not at all.

My cats literally depended on these snacks. I can’t understand the motivation to remove the valuable, functioning item and replace it with one that doesn’t anymore than I can understand the dishonest motivation to advertise it as the same product which is happening even in stores with clerks.

The ingredients lists are clearly not the same. I’m disappointed in this company which I have for so long raved about the benefit of their products to other cat parents and honestly feel betrayed as these companies know our pets are our family members.

I had never heard of this product nor this brand, but I received a free sample and was excited to see how my kitty would take to it. She is usually quite picky, acting as if she is royalty who only deserves the best of the best, so if something is not top-of-the-line stuff, she will stick her nose up at it and scoff, How dare you assume I will lower myself for such trash! However, upon opening one of the squeeze-packets, it only took a matter of a few seconds before my cat showed up and devoured the entire thing – devoured is not even the right word she basically inhaled the food, wasting no time in making sure she ate every last bit.

The crazy did not stop there, for kitty was not done yet and wanted some more. So, I gave another packet, then another and then the start of her fourth packet when my German shepherd butted in and wanted some! I could not leave pup-pup hanging so I gave the rest of Packet 4 to doggy.

Oh my, that turned out to be either a huge mistake or the beginning of an idea on how to entertain myself. The last packet, the oh-so-coveted 5, was desired by both kitty and puppy, and neither wanted to share.

I was at a loss on what to do but they took it into their own hands – I mean paws – and battled it out for dibbs. It was a strange and silly wrestling match between two sweet, but selfish animals who badly wanted that food but did not want to cause any harm.

It looked more like intense hugging than a fight, but ultimately the both lost, or both won, or whatever, who cares. I split it between them, and they gave me some evil eyes but they soon understood my reason for the split.

Now my pets keep trying to give off hints, like how my cat wrote Moar tuna squeezie in her litter, and puppy somehow learned basic English and barks out Do not give that cat what is mine! while pointing a paw at the empty sample box.

I would have given a perfect rating but the ingredients are not the best, buttery are not awful either. They are mid-road. The price seems reasonable and I will definitely be buying more for kitty and puppy! I recommend these unless you only buy all organic.

Your pets may just surprise you with how they react! I received a free sample of this product in exchange for my honest review.

I received the Delectables Squeeze Up with Tuna & Salmon 4 Pack Sample for Free from PINCHme and was really looking forward to having my cat Marilla try it out as I was able to try this type of product previously with another Brand through PINCHme and that’s how I found her love for this stuff, some Brands more than others.

Now, when I opened this product, it states it’s Tuna & Salmon, but I had to even ask my grandmother’s opinion because it legitimately smelled like a roaster chicken or like Thanksgiving gravy turkey and I was like oh boy because she hates chicken, beef, etc.

, she’s a seafood gal, but then when I went to give it to her, she went nuts and literally licked that bowl until it was sparkling clean!! Thus far there’s other Brands that she enjoys, but I’m thinking this one is her Favorite.

I do like that there’s not a long laundry list of unhealthy ingredients. Overall I’m pleased with the Ingredients in this Product. Marilla’s also specific to Pate wet food, so the another thing that I like about these squeeze ups is the consistency of them, Delectables is very smooth and silky, doesn’t have a real thick consistency, and I just add a little bit of hot water to it and it’s perfection to her, so I’m definitely going to keep my eye out for it and see if I can find it in the stores and if not order it online and I would recommend it, it’s great to use in between meals.

She is a small cat my grandparents and I used to give her breakfast and dinner, but she spreads her breakfast out pretty much the entirety of the day and there’s only a couple days here and there where she’ll finish it maybe around noon time, so we stopped giving her dinner wet food because she would just leave it and it would get wasted and thrown in the garbage, so what I’ve noticed about these puree treats is the couple of days where she finishes her food early I end up giving her this in her bowl to fill her up for the rest of the day and it works out perfect.

She’s not having it every day so it’s always a nice treat for her and it works out perfectly with her meal time situation, so I’m very happy I was able to try this!.

Talk about Clean Plater Club! As I pour this into the serving dish my initial thoughts were “this is an awfully big portion size” but let me tell you my fur baby devoured every single bit in a single session and licked the bowl completely clean.

I was surprised to open the package and learn this treat was unlike any other texture of food products I had previously given my kitty. It truly was a bisque, just like you would be served in a nice restaurant.

It also had a strong, attention-grabbing aroma. The bisque dispensed easily into a bowl from the easy-tear, easy-pour package and I quickly placed it down for my fur baby who at this point had begun to make quite the ruckus.

She eagerly lapped it up and did not budge until her dish was completely emptied. Afterwards she spent quite a bit of time prancing around the house looking out windows and doors and jumping around in a playful kitty manner to demonstrate her delight for the treat she had just been given.

I received a free sample of Hartz Delectables Lickable Treat – Bisque with Tuna & Salmon but opinions are completely my (and my fur baby’s) own.

Receiving this was so nice! I was not expecting it to look the way it does, but I love it. It really looks like a Hershey’s chocolate bar with mini break away pieces. I think it’s a very nice product just by the looks.

I broke off one square to give Kiwi, and he loved it. I think the smell of the chicken and the flavor was perfect for him. The product does have a strong scent, so if that’s something you do not like then that is one thing I would say be cautious about.

My cat enjoyed the first square so much he nudged at the package after I set it down and closed it. The little pieces are easy to break apart, wether you want to give just one piece or a couple pieces.

I usually give him two pieces after he comes inside and he really enjoys them, he usually naps after eating them. The item itself doesn’t put him to sleep that’s just what he does. The box is also an easy to open package and very slim to throw in a drawer.

I will definitely be going out to buy these for him. I also looked up the price range for them, and they are a nice price for my liking. I recommend these, if you are trying to look for some new treats for your feline friend.

My cat, Coltrane, loooveess salmon! And now with these treats, he can enjoy a little taste of real salmon. I put it into a shallow dish and he licks the bowl clean! And comes asking for more. I took off one star because the packaging for this product is a little ridiculous.

It had an easy tear bag that was resealable, and then 10 small pouches of portioned treats. Sounds good in theory, but I go to tear open the bag and it completely ripped in half. I stored them in some random tupperware container, so there’s no harm, but it’s a waste of plastic and a waste of product design.

Highly recommend this treat for a cat who enjoys the “good stuff” humans are eating for dinner!.

My female only likes this treat, she won’t touch the others. Fancy feast flaked tuna treats. We have other cats that will eat some of the other flavors. Thank goodness, for non picky eaters. I find them often out of stock, so try to order an abundant for her and to share if need be.

We also have a 21 year old, whose loosing weight daily, she eats very little. She will eat this and am greatful that she’ll eat anything. She’s in no pain, just slow and she gets 2 treats plus some wet food with extra water.

She licks her wet food and eats her 2 daily treats. Greatful to still have her in our life. Thanks Chewy for having such a variety of good stuff.

Wavered between four stars and three, but since one of the problems is them not being very good for the cat, I left it as four, as they are a treat. Then back to three as my second complaint is pretty strong.

Cat likes them but I have two issues with them. One- they are pretty large and there is no way to close it so save it for later without clips to fold it into carefully. Understandable though, and a me problem.

Two, once ripped open by the tab, the edges are relatively soft, except the hard edge you start the tear from. There there is a hard, sharp edge that I can do little about. It’s just like the edge of a freezie.

I wish that side softened as it got close to the feeding edge. It’s right where the cat licks. I was constantly wary and worried about her cutting her tongue on it, which I see as a very real possibility.

For that reason I’ve only used two and am always put off to wanting to use known safer treats, instead. I don’t know if a cat ever has cut themselves on this, maybe never, but it makes me mildly anxious about it happening and I don’t want an insane vet bill and a miserable cat dealing with a sliced tongue.

If you have a way to soften the edge, or if you just squeeze it out into a dish, then I recommend.

I especially like that the ingredients are simple with no by-product or meal like many of the other lickable treats, just: Water Sufficient For Processing, Chicken, Modified Tapioca Starch, Natural Flavor, Chicken Liver, Rice Bran Oil, Locust Bean Gum, Taurine.

It’s not easy feeding my two at the same time as they nudge and push to get their licks, might have to try one in each hand. Pricing is okay as it comes out to be almost. 50 cents a tube, versus most which are usually about a dollar per tube for the same amount.

Each individual tube is. 50 oz. and there are 5 tubes per package, giving you 2. 5 oz per package.

My cat absolutely loves these! He’s allowed one a day, in the evening. Holding out one of his “lickies” is a sure-fire way to make him come in the house when he’s being stubborn. I add a couple of packages of them to my usual order of cat food, and as always, Pet Max sees that they are delivered promptly and in excellent condition.

The price is better than what I would pay locally. I discovered Pet Max when my local stores were out of my usual cat food during the worst days of the pandemic, and I have never been disappointed in their selection, quality and price.

I don’t buy my pet needs anywhere else now.

Having had a diabetic cat in the past (treated for 2 years before he passed) I’m well versed in cat nutrition, especially carbohydrates, moisture content and nutrients+ingredients. We currently have 4 cats and we’ve highly limited carbs and other harmful ingredients as much as we can in their twice daily meals.

These treats aren’t much different from the other brands available, but they’re healthier than most that are in the same price range and retail availability. We’d normally never give treats, however, these treats have become necessary to reinforce good behaviour.

One of the cats was diagnosed with asthma in late 2019 and we have to give him medication every night. This involves a special aerochamber (AeroKat) and an inhaler. He has to take 14 full breaths while wearing the mask piece before he’s released from his light hold spot on our kitchen counter.

At first he was very resistant (as you can imagine. ), but we quickly learned that the best way to make this as easy and less traumatic as possible (he’s had traumatic vet visits and is very fearful of being restrained) is to give him a treat afterwards to reward him for his good behaviour and cooperation.

As a result, every night around 9pm he has his cute little routine of meowing and rolling around next to the cabinet where we keep the treats. He knows the routine and he’s looking forward to his treat! 😊 However, if you’ve had multiple cats at once you’ll know what that means lol The other 3 cats are also in the kitchen waiting for a treat! There’s no way to avoid breaking their hearts if we were to only give him a treat and not the others.

so they each get one (or 2 if my husband is doing it) after the inhaler has been done. Obviously, 4+ treats per day means that the bags are too expensive and get emptied quickly. So we’ve been buying the 9.

75 oz value size tubs from Amazon which is cheaper overall, more convenient and less wasteful, but the treats still kind of dry out over time because the seal of the top isn’t. well, sealed. That’s why I removed a star.

I like that they’re not too moist or slimy (they don’t rot or get sticky), they’re small (but not too small either, can be used with teenage kittens), and they don’t smell horrible (I still wash my hands afterwards because it’s not a pleasant smell to constantly have on your hands).

The catnip flavour is a favourite, but the salmon one is a good one too. Chicken wasn’t well liked. However, I wish that the label was removable instead of printed on. They’re great sized containers that I’d like to reuse, but I haven’t found any way to remove the label.

It would be a plus in my opinion of the company as it would show a bit more that they care about the environment and encourage reusing their packaging. The small size of the bags are wasteful in my opinion since they go straight to the trash once empty.

Last note: I just noticed that they recommend 8 treats twice a day for a 10 lbs cat. That’s ridiculous. They’re marketed as dental treats, but I don’t think they’re big enough to do any cleaning. At that rate their nutritional intake is going to be highly negatively impacted while maybe getting a slight gum/teeth stimulation.

I don’t recommend that, especially if you already feed your cat dry food. Also, one of my cats swallows it whole 98% of the time, so it’s not necessarily good for all cats. I suggest buying a small pouch to try it out first.

We originally bought these Catnip Greenies for our cats to assist them with teeth & gum health. An unexpected good side effect is that the catnip has had another positive side effect on one of our cats well being.

Jemima has always had an unusual personality- she was quite cranky and did not like to be touched at all. She seemed to want to be stroked as she would purr but would very quickly bite whoever was stroking her.

We just accepted that was her and put it down to early trauma as she was a stray & skinny kitten when we found her at 3 months old. She is now four years old and has always been like this – until the catnip Greenies! The catnip Greenies have completely changed her personality! She is now very cuddly, revels in a vigorous stroking session and seeks us out to snuggle! She seems much more relaxed and happy! We give her the recommended 8 biscuits a day and this keeps her calm & happy! Our other cat has the same, but it doesn’t seem to have the same affect or much of any affect on him – he’s always been very relaxed anyway.

So, I highly recommend anyone whose cat is a little anxious (or weirdly bites!) to give them a try – she’s clearly much happier and now gets to enjoy cuddles!.

I have two cats, one of whom is quite the glutton and will eat almost anything (except neither cat will touch the freeze-dried treats from a certain famous chef and his Maine Coon). So, I really wasn’t expecting them to not eat this, but I was shocked when the gluttonous cat actually TROTS to get these treats! He usually just sits there and loudly demands food, but for these he will actively move his body to get to them before the other cat! These are pretty big, so they don’t need as many of them.

I guess that’s also good because they are actually forced to chew them, hence the dental cleaning aspect. We have purchased lots of other dental treats which are smaller that the cats basically swallow whole.

I took off one star because all of the Greenies treats are much more expensive than the other brands, but if you’re just looking for a review on whether the cats like them they get 5 stars. If they actually work to keep their teeth clean (too soon to tell), then I guess it’s worth it.

Otherwise they’re just pretty expensive treats.

When we adopted our male Bengal, he hadn’t been trained AT ALL. Potty trained – yes, but otherwise he had NO training. ALSO, he didn’t like treats. NOT AT ALL. Our female was/is so much easier since we’ve had her since she was 4 months, but getting a strong-willed, food-focused 2 1/2 year old male meant we HAD to find a treat that he’d go to the moon for.

This is it. He hears me tear along the perforated lines and he is immediately AT MY SIDE in a perfect “sit. ” Our female won’t touch them, but it’s okay. Our big, beautiful boy loves them and will perform all the fun tricks (as well as some of the necessary commands) just to get even a piece of one of these.

I began purchasing these Sheba Meaty Tender Sticks for my cat CJ, close to a year ago now and he loves them, scarfing them down way too quickly every single time. I have 2 small dogs and we give them chewy sticks fairly regularly, as a treat, but when CJ would continuously try stealing the dogs’ we decided to get similar sticks but for cats.

Sheba is a trustworthy, affordable brand that I grew up feeding to my cats, and now as an adult, I choose to purchase it for my pets. Sheba’s sticks are tender, have little to no smell, and come individually packaged but still attached to one another, keeping them soft, fresh, and convenient for a quick grab and go experience.

I’ve only ever seen them offered in 2 flavors; Salmon and Chicken. CJ prefers seafood so naturally he flocks to the Salmon flavor more, but he will definitely eat the chicken flavor and not think twice about it! I Highly recommend these for any cat who enjoys a more softer chew treat and likes to carry it around somewhat like a dog.

I posted about Shebas Salmon Sticks which I gave 5 ⭐️ because Lil Girl gobbles those right up. The chicken sticks she will eat but not with such enthusiasm. Sometimes she’ll leave some behind. Like I said in the Salmon Sticks, their a healthy treat with no preservatives or fillers.

Each stick comes individually wrapped in a foil packet keeping them fresh. I don’t like all the trash they produce though. The treats are pretty pricey but I’m willing to pay the price for the salmon flavors because she enjoys them so much.

It’s the least I can do for her because she brings so much joy to my life.

I have had several cats with kidney failure and each time, with the considerable help of a brilliant vet, I’ve learned more and more. My Siamese cat George has kidney failure, heart failure, pleurisy, pancreatitis and no teeth! He’s always been fussy about his food – now even more so.

Whilst renal foods are good for ‘kidney’ cats, I have learned the most important thing is high calorific intake. George eats little at a time so I have feed him 5 times per day. He gets conventional wet and dry food, but sometimes he eats very little.

However, he nearly always eats Dreamies and would eat 50 at a time – if I let him! When he was 8 years old, at one point, the vet thought he would not last overnight. He’s now 11 and is as happy and healthy as he can be.

Dreamies have helped to keep his weight up (he’s a healthy 4kg) and he eats (far too many!) them every day, even on days when he’s ‘off’ his conventional food. I can see Dreamies actually stimulate his appetite for conventional food.

I am convinced that George would not be alive today without Dreamies. Please see attached from a couple of weeks ago (I’d love to send you a video of him leaping around recently). Thank you so much for your great product.

Once upon a time, in this galaxy, not so long ago, If I wanted my cats, I had to search out their napping spot. While dogs will come at any sound you make, cats are selectively deaf. That all changed when we were given a pouch of Dreamies as a housewarming gift for our new rescue cat.

Guaranteed to make the transition to the new home easier for the cat, I had no idea what effect it would have on our first rescue cat. Within days, both cats had been cured of their “deafness,” even from a sound asleep.

A wee shake of the Dreamies pouch and within moments I am at the centre of a purr-fest! While they love all the flavours, varieties and mixes, I believe chicken brings the loudest purr. Inspired by the Dreamies commercials, we have experimented to see how fast and far the cats will respond to the “wee shake of the pouch,” but my favourite game is hide and seek.

I shake the pouch then hide someplace where I can watch their frustrated search. (Rather like when I searched for their hiding spots. ) My laughter usually ends the game before they find me, but one day I might duct tape my mouth shut so they can track me down.

(Glad these are made in the UK so Brexit won’t disrupt our Dreamies supply!).

There was some trepidation from my two when I bought this. It didn’t crinkle like the packet to signal there was cheesy goodness on the horizon. They both looked at me in disbelief the first time I shook the box, probably under the impression that I was trying to palm them off with dry food instead of treats.

But my Lord, they learnt that sound fast. To the point when reaching into the top cupboard (where I have had to take to storing them because they can open the bottom one and get in the box) for some spices, to go in the beautiful meal I was cooking, stupidly with knife in hand.

I accidentally dislodged the box, causing it to fall out of the cupboard, at which point the eldest cat came flying through the open window like Superman flying round the world to save Louis (he had obviously been waiting for such opportunies) scaring the living bejesus out of me.

The spices flew, the knife flew and I flew (though with no where near as much grace as the cat) all in different directions. He fell on those spilled treats with zealous. Though not as fast as I fell to the floor.

The only thing that seemed to be moving slow was the knife as it fell. Into my leg. I highly recommend this product. The cat loves them. Enough for me to spend 5 hours in A and E.

I have 5 outdoor cats, 3 of which prefer dry treats while the other two prefer moist ones. With that said, I’m always finding and trying new treats that would be a crowd pleaser. When I received my free sample of Delectable Squeeze Up with Tuna & Salmon Flavor from PINCHme, I was excited to see which one of my cats would enjoy it.

Blackie, my shy girl with a well-rounded palette enjoyed licking the squeeze up. She especially loves shoving her nose in it. Meeki, Ms. Picky Eater, took a sniff before trying a lick and decided it wasn’t for her.

She walked directly to the container of dry treats and sat in front of it waiting patiently. Moko, Meeki’s brother, at first was more interested in the wrapper than the treat itself, however after getting a taste of it, he attempted to eat the product whole, plastic and all.

Lucky, my I’m only interested in sleeping in the sun fluffy boy, was absolutely not interested in it. Like Meeki, he’s the dry treat type except you have to bring the treat to him, lol. Zeemi, my energetic & adventurous girl, seem to like the treat but wasn’t exactly interested in the tube the treat was in.

Or maybe I wasn’t squeezing it fast enough. When giving her treats, she loves receiving her dry treats in a ball dispenser so it might have been too boring for her. Overall, 2 out of 5 enjoyed the Delectable Squeeze Ups.

Blackie, Moko and I had the most fun with this type of treat which I look forward to getting for them. Moko can be seen in the photos with Meeki waiting for her dry treats!.

Thanks to Hartz, I was gifted their Delectables Squeeze Up Tuna & Salmon 4 Count in exchange for my honest review. Boy, does my cat love the entire Delectables line, but especially this new Tuna & Salmon flavor.

At first smell, it was a reluctant nose up sniff or two, a sudden step back, a couple lip licks, and then he immediately came back and began the whole “can’t eat it fast enough” ordeal, which is his typical reaction to the Delectables treats.

He loves them. If I had to state one treat or snack that he would want, any time, of any day, any mood, even after any worst time of his life situations such as miscellaneous examinations, bath time, harness dress out, ear medicine, butt cleaning, post scolding, etc, it would be the Hartz Delectables Tuna & Salmon.

They are fun as an interactive or bonding time between owner and pet, or a snack that you squeeze into a small bowl for independent eating. They don’t have any strong odors or fish smells and they aren’t messy whatsoever.

They are easy to tear open, easy to squeeze, and easy for your pet to eat.

If Joe could give these a million stars, I’m sure he would! His drool, speaks for itself. (i mean, who knew cats drool! – he doesn’t usually, only when these bad boys come out and instantly he is drooling and begging for the entire container 🤤) As soon as he sees me going near where the treats are kept, he instantly talks to me, and tries to paw at the container and when i open it, he’s trying with all his might to stick his face and paws in to get as many as he can! He goes crazy for them! He likes almost every flavor we have gotten for him! The ferals/strays that we take care of, at our house and at my boyfriend job, (like atleast 10 to 15 of them) and they all love these yummy treats! So, it’s safe to say, they’re definitely kitty cat approved! Human approved as well! You get a really big container for a decent price! And if you only want a little bag, they have those for two bucks.

(in my area!) The only issue I have with the product, is with the container lid. So they’re is a smaller opening/lid, so you can pour some out. Unfortunately, (on like 3 out 5 containers) the little triangle opening always breaks and it technically can be placed on the top so the treats don’t go stale, but it’s not always easy and it isn’t sturdy, and sometimes while I’m trying to set it on there, it falls in.

So, of they could make the mini lid opening a little more sturdy, or a new concept, it would be 100% absolutely wonderful! But sense the lid isn’t that big of a deal and can be fixed by putting some foil over or under or transferring the treats to a different container etc, it’s all good! Just a minor annoyance.

🤷.

Three out of six cats I have, the left one is the mother to the two kitties in picture. The other two are not in picture. I’ve been dieting my cats with feeding them only once a day (still giving them full serving size and little extra), for about two months now.

They were grossly overweight and you could clearly tell the momma cat was having issues playing and even breathing (we rescued her from behind a truck engine, she had motor oil ALL over her and caked in her face).

Well, I still wanted to treat them to something nice that was not going to cause excessive weight gain or keep them overweight/at same weight they were at that time. So, I started giving them Temptations once a day and they love it! They lost three pounds and are now only two pounds away from being at a healthy weight.

Peep (momma cat) isn’t breathing heavy anymore AND she’s playful again! She actually chases the laser and runs after the cat wand. She doesn’t fall over from being obese. Thanks to Temptations, my cats learned how to properly eat and NOT over eat.

Sloopy (kitty on right side) and his twin (not pictured), don’t over eat to the point of vomiting. I give four stars because the plastic lids on any container NEVER seal/shut properly and I have to put the treats in a zip lock bag.

Why am I spending $9-$10 on a container so poorly made?.

Temptations has spoiled all 6 of my cats! The level of obsession, particularly for my gray cat – Kylo, is through the roof. He gets extremely immersed in eating Temptations. Dairy flavor is one flavor he gets now and then.

And, when he gets them – the happiness is evident. Kylo is so extremely thrilled with Temptations that he will jump on the washing machine (where we keep new bags), jump back down to the floor with large bag in his mouth, carry the large bag out of the laundry room, through the kitchen, through the hallway and foyer, up the stairs, into my bedroom, and jump on my bed with the bag in his mouth! I’m not joking! He will then release the bag onto the bed and look up at me with big, saucer eyes waiting for me to open the bag and disperse treats.

Well, I guess after all he did, the least I can do is serve them up on my quilt. In a pinch, he will claw and use his teeth to get the treats himself. He is very resourceful. I’m pretty sure your cat will love them too but I cannot promise your cat will bring them to you.

Catit. CLEARLY a company that LOVES cats! ALL of my girls get their Creamy Treats, once during the day, and again before bed. It contains TAURINE. EXCELLENT for their eyes (and other benefits. please Google).

They LOVE all flavors. It’s good, it’s healthy! TREAT your furbabies with these healthy treats. The offer a multi-flavor pack if you’re buying for the 1st time. I’ll tell you why I genuinely LOVE Catit products.

Over the years I have bought things for my cats, toys, treats, catnip, etc. I purchased on what I thought they’d like, if a snack I read the ingredients, the quality (where grown) and quantity of catnip (plant and spray), etc.

Without ever ONCE looking to see who the manufacturer was. Then one day Catit comes across my (FB I think it was) feed. So I started going around the house to check on all the stuff here for my cats.

And I couldn’t believe how much of it was Catit. Again. they CLEARLY LOVE cats! And yours will LOVE Catit Creamy Treats! @catit. YUM!.

Since these are labeled “cat treats,” I mistakenly assumed they’d be edible by cats right out of the bag. No. They are whole, large hearts, and they’re hard as a brick. I have to saw at them with a steak knife to mince them into something edible, which is messy and likely unsanitary, since the bag advises you about washing things thoroughly with hot, soapy water after touching the treats.

While I’m no stranger to excessive efforts for my cats, I really just wanted small treats I could sprinkle as a food topper. Since other cat treats by this brand come in that format, I expected these would, too.

They apparently taste okay once I have minced them, but I won’t buy these again. I’ll stick with the duck livers and other treats that are actually minced in the bag. Disappointed.

We have been using these tarter control treats for years both as a special treat and for tarter. The vet is very happy with her teeth as she is 12 and never had to have teeth cleaned and no areas of concern at this time or past.

Not having to have her put under for cleaning procedure makes us really happy. We have tried Greenies and other treats but they don’t make her happy like these. We like the built in dental care we get with these.

So glad that Chewy had this item. As we all know, cat food is very hard 2 find in markets these days; and even on Chewy, some items r not 2 b found. However, I always go back 2 Chewy. Have been ordering from them now 4 a few years.

My little furry guys love all the food. Wish they could get the items back in; as I really only like ordering from them. So easy.

I started buying them for my very finicky two spoiled house casts a number of months ago. I have tried many treats but mostly my cats turned up their noses, but they go bonkers for these. I have to keep them locked up or my 22 pound Manx breaks it open and eats half of them.

But I began three months ago giving some to my brother to feed his frail probably dying, slowly, 20+ year old cat which had belonged to my late mother, so we are trying to do the best we can for the old Matriarch.

And she is. So now I try to make sure he has at least 1. 5 containers, preferably 2 containers, per month because Sophia, his cat, is eating very poorly, only canned no more dry, but she will eat these and he is feeding her a lot of them as she had become emaciated this fall from not eating enough, and since supplementing her food with these she has gained weight and is feeling better.

We realize it isn’t ideal cat food and something else would be far more nutritious, and I assure you we have tried all the best old age foods, and she won’t touch them. And we can’t afford to keep buying food she wont eat.

So anyway, we are grateful for this, it is keeping her with us a few more months. We didn’t expect her to make it through the winter. Actually she is frail and strong. She was a very strong spirited kitty all her life and that is also what keeps her alive, along with these nice goodies and her fierce love for her Daddy, my brother.

I bought two of the Salmon Jumbo Stuff Temptations and two more of the Tuna variety, plus two packs of Greenies Smartbites. Five out of six were slashed down the side, treats everywhere. My well-meaning parents who gathered up the mess also destroyed the evidence, though.

Honestly, this is strange. It really doesn’t look like an accident, but what was the purpose of it? I’ve order from Chewy many times and this has never happened before. Small accidents maybe. Not what looks like outright sabotage from whoever packaged these.

Three stars for the product. Minus two for. whatever just happened.

I think the question here should say not “what I think about this product” it’s “what my cat thinks about this product”. I have two cats and this Temptations classic is their favorite they go nuts when I get out of the closet.

I think they can tell by the color of the bag or maybe it’s just the smell. I tried to rotate with the other flavors but always come back to this I love to watch my cat do the little dance in and out of my legs rubbing up and down my thigh.

Be careful at 2 cal per treat they will make your little babies fat! Honestly, I really don’t think my cat cares if she’s fat she just wants more we called this “kitty crack” because they will do anything for it.